Butter Wonderpath
Home / Flavors

Our gelato & ice cream

Churned fresh daily in small batches. Our lineup rotates with the seasons, so there's always a new flavor to discover.

Classics

Year-round favorites
  • Madagascar vanilla bean$9

    Pure Madagascar vanilla, smooth cream, and a hint of bourbon notes.

  • Pistachio gelato$8

    Salted caramel gelato, roasted hazelnut swirl, candied praline and a drizzle of dark chocolate.

  • Chocolate & hazelnut sundae$7

    Fresh strawberry gelato, wild honey, crushed pistachio and a touch of cream.

  • Dark chocolate & sea salt$10

    Velvety dark chocolate, hand-harvested sea salt flakes, and a whisper of espresso.

  • The sundae special$13

    Your choice of two gelato flavors, whipped cream, hot fudge, roasted nuts and a cherry on top.

Seasonal flavors & specials

Available now while in stock
  • Madagascar vanilla$4

    Churned slowly in small batches for the smoothest, creamiest texture.

  • Dark chocolate$5

    Rich, dense and best enjoyed at the counter — grab a spoon and dive in.

  • Pistachio gelato$5

    Pistachio, dark chocolate and a sprinkle of crushed amaretti.

  • Affogato$5

    Vanilla gelato drowned in a shot of hot espresso.

  • Seasonal fruit sorbet$6

    A bright, refreshing ice made from whatever fruit is ripest this week.

  • Signature gelato base$7

    Made fresh daily with whole milk, cream and real vanilla. Pair it with any flavor.

Sweet treats all day

Available from opening
  • Gelato sundae$9

    Two scoops of gelato topped with fresh whipped cream and your choice of sauce.

  • Berry gelato trio$10

    Three of our finest fruit flavors — strawberry, raspberry and blackcurrant — in one bowl.

  • Chocolate lovers' sundae$11

    Dark chocolate gelato, warm chocolate sauce, roasted hazelnuts and crispy wafers.

  • Salted caramel swirl$9

    Creamy vanilla gelato ribboned with homemade salted caramel and sea salt flakes.

Gelato & extras

Fresh flavors made daily
  • Double scoop$3

    Two flavors to explore, served in a cup or cone.

  • Blood orange$4

    Triple scoop supreme

  • Seasonal fruit$4

    A rotating single origin, made fresh in small batches.

  • Salted caramel$5

    House-made syrups, fresh fruit, and your choice of toppings.

  • Affogato$5

    Warm vanilla gelato, a shot of espresso poured over, finished with cocoa.

  • Sorbetto$4

    Fruit-forward and dairy-free, made with seasonal produce and nothing else.

Got an allergy or a preference? Just ask at the counter — we're happy to talk you through what's in everything, and there's always a dairy-free sorbetto on the board.
Staff favorites

What we'd scoop

If it's your first time in, start here — these three are gone by mid-afternoon most days.

A bowl of salted caramel gelato with a wooden spoon
Everyone's favorite

Artisan Sundae Bar

Made fresh throughout the day. Get it while it's still at the perfect temperature.

A generous scoop of dark chocolate gelato dusted with cocoa powder
The classic

Seasonal Flavors From Local Fruit

Single-origin cocoa and a hint of sea salt. The reason we opened.

A pristine pistachio gelato in a crisp cone
Best seller

Creamy Gelato

Creamy, nutty, and made with real Sicilian pistachio paste. A gelato bar essential.

Traditional Italian Ice Cream Techniques

Weekends fill up fast. Reserve your spot and we'll have a fresh scoop and a quiet corner waiting for you.